Sammy's Pizzeria

Sammy's Pizzeria, located in Niagara Falls, NY, has garnered a mix of praise and constructive feedback from patrons. Reviews highlight the delicious New York-style pizzas, particularly the deeply satisfying deep-dish with a sesame crust, although some diners suggest sticking to the regular crust next time for optimal flavor. The salads, especially the Greek salad, also received commendations for their freshness and quality. Service at Sammy's can be hit or miss: while many have enjoyed friendly interactions, inconsistencies in timing have been noted, particularly when ordering multiple items. For instance, one customer experienced perfectly cooked wings paired with slightly dried-out pizza due to the timing of their preparation. Despite these hiccups, the dining experience remains largely positive. The atmosphere is described as casual and nostalgic, with an “iconic” status among long-time patrons who have been visiting for decades. Although some note that the interior could be warmer and more comfortable on hot days, the pizzas' great flavors and quality keep customers coming back for more. Many, including Canadian visitors, appreciate the value offered by Sammy's, especially with special combos like a half tray of pizza paired with wings. In summary, Sammy's Pizzeria is a delightful option for pizza lovers, especially those looking for a taste of classic American cuisine in a laid-back setting.